Since I do not use artificial sweeteners I had thought it would be hard to find things to satisfy my sweet tooth. As far as I can tell, all low cal/diet desserts have some sort of artificial sweetener. So far, this is what I have come up with instead:
Jello pudding (the regular kind, not low or no cal): These only have 120 calories per serving which is the same amount in many low calorie artificially sweetened diet dessert products (such as Yoplait Parfaits). Well, and unlike the ad we don't have to "make" jello pudding anymore.
100 Calorie Right Bites: Lots of different cookies to choose from! They are the same as regular cookies in small packets that only contain 100 calories. They are rather expensive at my regular grocery store, but Target (and I am sure Walmart) have them at a reasonable price.
Oikos organic greek yogurt, chocolate or caramel: I really like these, especially the caramel since I have cut out my caramel fraps. Only 110 calories.
Bags of miniature candy bars: Safe if you only eat 1 or 2. This one is kind of hard for me because I have a big weakness for candy bars. :-)